Justin Gutmann has been certified to act as class representative and the claim has been certified to proceed on an opt-out basis. The CPO Judgment is available here and a copy of the CPO Notice is available here.

Justin Gutmann, the Proposed Class Representative in the Loyalty Penalty Claim, has filed applications to bring collective proceedings against Three, O2, EE and Vodafone in the Competition Appeal Tribunal. All relevant documents will be uploaded to this page as the Loyalty Penalty Claim progresses.

The Tribunal has reviewed the Loyalty Penalty Claim applications and has published summaries on its website, which can be viewed by clicking the links below:

Collective Proceedings Order

Collective Proceedings Order - Justin Gutmann v Vodafone Limited and Vodafone Group PLC

Collective Proceedings Order - Justin Gutmann v EE Limited and BT Group PLC

Collective Proceedings Order - Justin Gutmann v Hutchison 3G UK Limited

Collective Proceedings Order - Justin Gutmann v Telefonica UK Limited

 

Judgment 

Judgment Certification and Limitation

Judgment Certification and Limitation (summary)

 

Summary of Claim Form

Summary of Claim Form in Justin Gutmann v Vodafone Limited and Vodafone Group PLC

Summary of Claim Form in Justin Gutmann v EE Limited and BT Group PLC

Summary of Claim Form in Justin Gutmann v Hutchison 3G UK Limited

Summary of Claim Form in Justin Gutmann v Telefonica UK Limited

 

Public Notices

CPO Notice

CPO Application and Hearing Notice

Register today

  1. Fill in the form:

    Registering for updates is free; your details will be kept secure.
  2. Updates:

    As the case progresses, we will keep you updated.
  3. Conclusion:

    In the event the claims are successful, or there is a settlement, we will send you details on how to verify eligibility and make a claim for damages. 
Please provide a valid value for First Name
Please provide a valid value for Last Name
(optional)
Please provide a valid value for Current Contact Number
Please provide a value for Please select all the mobile network operators that you have entered into a contract with, you can select multiple options.
© 2025 Case Pilots, all rights reserved.